Balsamic Vinegars

Our Balsamic Vinegars are sourced from the most respected producers in Modena, Italy.

PGI (Protected Geographical Indication) Certified by the European Union.
Evaluated by the AIB (Italian Association of Balsamic Tasters) and awarded 3 or 4 Leaf quality ratings.
Tart to sweet, flavored to non-flavored, white to dark, and medium to thick densities.
Our vinegars are naturally flavored, contain no added sugars and are gluten-free.

We strive to provide you with as much descriptive detail as possible in case you are not able to taste and experience the distinct flavors in one of our stores. We have developed a simple Sweetness Scale of 1-5: The higher the number, the sweeter the taste. The smaller the number, more tart. Our “Riserva” Balsamic Vinegars are rich and thick.

PLEASE NOTE: Product selection and availability varies in our store. Please call the store directly to confirm specific product availability.

Nutritional Information on our Balsamic Vinegars

PLEASE NOTE: Product selection and availability varies. Please call the store directly to confirm specific product availability or Contact Us via our convenient form.

Our Aged Balsamic Vinegars

Aceto Balsamico di Modena, 4 Leaf

This is our finest and most popular On-Tap Balsamic Vinegar of Modena. Formerly called Traditional 18 Year Style Balsamic Vinegar. PGI Certified. It is made utilizing the Solara method of progressive wood barrels. Learn More & Pricing

Aceto Balsamico di Modena, Riserva

Produced using a secret recipe handed down from father to son over 3 centuries, this is a very rich and thick traditional style Balsamic Vinegar of Modena is similar to the 25 Star/25 Year Style Balsamic Vinegars. Learn More & Pricing

Apricot Balsamic Vinegar

Lovers of Apricot flavor are going to really enjoy this delicious Balsamic Vinegar. The producer has captured the essence of ripe Italian Imola Royal Apricots and added them to a high quality Balsamic Vinegar of Modena. Learn More & Pricing

Blackberry Riserva Balsamic Vinegar

The Olive Tap’s Blackberry Balsamic Riserva Vinegar immediately delivers a deep and tantalizing berry flavor which lingers gently on the palate. The sweet-tart Blackberry flavor beautifully compliments the full flavored, dark Balsamic Vinegar of Modena. Learn More & Pricing

Black Currant Balsamic Vinegar

Yet another selection that has our customers saying “WOW”. It is very sweet with a low 4.5% acidity level for a smooth finish. The Olive Tap’s Black Currant Balsamic Vinegar has a very complex taste that will delight the palate. Learn More & Pricing

Black Garlic Balsamic Vinegar

Black Garlic is processed over several weeks by heating the whole garlic bulb, which results in “black” cloves. This slow roasted development produces notes of sweet nuttiness. The sophisticated taste is smooth and soft with a sharpness that adds depth to any dish. Learn More & Pricing

Blood Orange Balsamic Vinegar

This complex vinegar absolutely explodes with the taste of freshly squeezed Italian Oranges! Simply citrus and delicious! The lingering citrus sensation makes this balsamic another perfect choice for refreshing mixed green salads with fruits, nuts, and robust cheeses.. Learn More & Pricing

Blueberry Balsamic Vinegar

Blueberry lovers really appreciate this addition to the Olive Tap’s extensive line of Balsamic Vinegars of Modena. Our first impression was that this would be a huge hit drizzled over fruit salads, and garden salads topped with fresh fruits. Learn More & Pricing

Bordeaux Cherry Riserva Balsamic Vinegar

Beautiful, dark, ripe, bordeaux cherry flavor enlivens this incredible rich and thick Italian aged balsamic vinegar, giving a modern twist to this time honored classic. The rich cherry flavor will excel at flavoring meats, cheeses and salads. Learn More & Pricing

Bourbon Maple Balsamic Vinegar

Maple lovers and foodies rejoice! This expertly crafted explosion of flavor bomb is unrivaled in taste and quality. It is a multi-dimensional balsamic that delivers rich and complex flavor notes of maple, honey, charred oak, and spices. Learn More & Pricing

Cinnamon Pear Balsamic Vinegar

Rich toasted cinnamon and the sweet taste of Pear are combined to make this savory and sweet Balsamic Vinegar. It makes a great marinade or glaze for pork or poultry. Pair it with Blood Orange Olive Oil for a delicious vinaigrette. Learn More & Pricing

Coconut White Balsamic Vinegar

This unique white balsamic is significantly thicker, intensely sweeter, exhibits a golden hue and absolutely explodes with the aroma and taste of fresh coconut! Outrageously delicious and complex with our Sorrento Lemon, Sorrento Orange and Persian Lime Olive Oils. Learn More & Pricing

Cranberry Orange Balsamic Vinegar

This thick and rich Balsamic Vinegar of Modena starts off with a prominent Orange flavor up front with more subtle tart Cranberry notes in the middle. The higher concentration of cooked grape must yields a sweet, less acidic Orange finish that lingers on the tongue. Learn More & Pricing

Cranberry Pear Balsamic Vinegar

The Olive Tap’s fall favorite Cranberry Pear is crisp and tart with a deep rose blush color. It is amazingly fruity with just a touch of sweetness and has many delightful culinary applications. Learn More & Pricing

Cranberry Walnut Riserva Balsamic Vinegar

This popular Olive Tap offering that is a tried and true crowd pleaser whenever it is served. Made with a blend of White Riserva Balsamic Vinegar and a special blend of seasonal flavors including cranberries and walnuts. Learn More & Pricing

Cucumber Melon Riserva Balsamic Vinegar

Thinking about how to stay refreshed on those hot summer days? Try our White Cucumber Melon Riserva Balsamic Vinegar. A taste so good you’ll want to drink it and guess what – you can! Learn More & Pricing

Dark Chocolate Balsamic Vinegar, 3 Leaf Quality

This is a velvety-sweet, and very flavorful Balsamic Vinegar of Modena. It is truly a Chocolate lovers dream come true! No need to wait for dessert! The chocolate aroma and flavor are unmistakable. Learn More & Pricing

Elderflower Balsamic Vinegar

Sweet-tart flavor and mildly acidic, The Olive Tap’s Elderflower Balsamic Vinegar offers a unique and distinctive taste to a broad range of culinary dishes. This vinegar is crisp and juicy with a floral aroma. Learn More & Pricing

Espresso Balsamic Vinegar

Espresso Coffee has been a chef’s secret ingredient for years, commonly used to flavor meats and chicken. Now you can bring the rich, sweet and complex flavors of dark roasted coffee and premium balsamic vinegar to any number of everyday dishes. Learn More & Pricing

Fig Riserva Balsamic Vinegar

Whole fruit flavor is added to a blend of 3 and 4 Leaf Quality Aceto Balsamico di Modena to produce our most balanced Balsamic Vinegar. Not too sweet and not too tart, it can be paired with every one of The Olive Tap’s Extra Virgin Olive Oils. Learn More & Pricing

Fig Habanero Balsamic Vinegar

One of our most popular balsamic vinegars, with sweet with very slight undertones of habanero. This is a great compliment to cheeses, salads, and as a glaze on pork, chicken, or roasted vegetables (especially Brussels Sprouts!). Learn More & Pricing

Garlic Cilantro Balsamic Vinegar

Clearly a popular flavored balsamic vinegar at The Olive Tap. This has been the essence of fresh garlic and cilantro added. It is so rich it tastes like slow roasted garlic. Learn More & Pricing

Granny Smith Apple Balsamic Vinegar

The aroma and taste of this delicious balsamic vinegar scream Granny Smith Apples! Its authentic, crisp-tart taste is refreshing with a lingering sweet-smooth finish. Our Granny Smith White Balsamic Vinegar is extremely versatile. Learn More & Pricing

Hickory Barbeque Balsamic Vinegar

Rich, sweet and smoky, The Olive Tap Hickory Barbeque Balsamic Vinegar can easily become your secret ingredient on the grill or in the kitchen. Charcoal grillers will get a flavor boost, and gas grillers will be able to add nice smoke flavors. Learn More & Pricing

Honey Ginger Balsamic Vinegar

We fell in love with is and think you will too. Honey Balsamic Vinegar is sulfite-free because it’s made from 100% natural honey and contains no additives. It has a crisp level of acidity and a sweet honey finish. Learn More & Pricing

Italian Herb Balsamic Vinegar

A new customer favorite! Popular herbs including Oregano and Marjoram flavor this refreshing, crisp-tart Balsamic Vinegar which may change how you approach salad dressing. Learn More & Pricing

Jalapeno Lime Balsamic Vinegar

The essence of Jalapeño and Lime is combined with white balsamic to create a unique and delicious drizzle. It features Reasonable heat primarily on your tongue, as you experience the delicious flavor of Jalepeño peppers and the burst of Lime at the end. Learn More & Pricing

Lemon White Riserva Balsamic Vinegar

The Olive Tap’s Lemon White Riserva is significantly thicker and intensely sweeter than typical with Balsamic Vinegars. It exhibit a golden hue that absolutely explodes with the taste of freshly squeezed Italian lemons! Learn More & Pricing

Pomegranate Balsamic Vinegar

Native to Mediterranean, Asian and Middle Eastern cultures, this fruit exhibits a sweet-tart flavor that is a perfect accompaniment to a wide range of foods. There are numerous reports on the health benefits of Pomegranate. Now get a health food that tastes great!! Learn More & Pricing

Pink Grapefruit Balsamic Vinegar

The Pino Nero grape variety produces earthy, but elegant rosé wines that are cool, crisp, and dry. The delightful crispness of this wine not only translates seamlessly into vinegar, but it blends beautifully with pink grapefruit. Learn More & Pricing

Mandarin Orange White Balsamic Vinegar

Believed by many to be the most delicious variety of Orange, Satsuma Mandarin Oranges have a sweet-tart flavor that when blended with premium White Balsamic Vinegar is incomparable. Learn More & Pricing

Orange Mango Balsamic Vinegar

Enjoy a taste of the tropics with this fruity blend of flavors, in this rich, dense, and sweet Balsamic Vinegar. The flavors of Mango and Orange give a tropical flair to any creative salad, and combines extremely well with our Lime and Lemon Olive Oils. Learn More & Pricing

Peach White Balsamic Vinegar

Pear White Balsamic Vinegar

The bright clean taste of fresh pears and a premium white balsamic vinegar come together to form the most perfectly flavored Pear Balsamic Vinegar we have ever tasted! One taste and we’re sure you will agree. It is fantastic! Learn More & Pricing

Pineapple White Balsamic Vinegar

If you like the taste of a fresh ripe Hawaiian Pineapple, then this Pineapple White Balsamic Vinegar is for you! Made primarily as salad vinegar, it is surprisingly well suited for use in cooking and grilling. Learn More & Pricing

Raspberry Balsamic Vinegar

This very popular Balsamic Vinegar is a tried and true crowd pleaser whenever it is served! It is one of the most adaptable Balsamic Vinegars, and can be used with any of the Olive Tap Extra Virgin Olive Oils to make flavorful Vinaigrettes. Learn More & Pricing

Raspberry White Riserva Balsamic Vinegar

Featuring a sweet and tangy up-front flavor, and a rich, bright Raspberry finish. This fruity Olive Tap Balsamic Vinegar will have unlimited potential in any kitchen. Learn More & Pricing

Serrano Pepper and Honey Balsamic Vinegar

This vinegar is sweet and tart, with the sting of Serrano heat! It’s made from 100% honey and is sulfite-free. Add a delicious and distinct, mellow flavor to salads, sauces, seafood, poultry, and vegetable dishes. Learn More & Pricing

Sicilian Lemon White Balsamic Vinegar

Refreshingly sweet with a delicate lemon tang. Our Sicilian Lemon White Balsamic Vinegar of Modena has nicely balanced acidity with a crisp lemon flavor and aroma. It makes an excellent substitute for lemon juice. Learn More & Pricing

Strawberry Balsamic Vinegar

A wonderful sweet-tart vinegar, sure to tantalize your taste buds. Whether it is on a salad of spring mix with tomato, cucumber and onion, or on baby spinach salad with hard boiled egg and walnuts, you will find yourself longing for just one more bite! Learn More & Pricing

Truffle Balsamic Vinegar

Our Truffle Balsamic Vinegar is infused with essence of truffles. The result is a sweet-tart, balsamic with rich, earthy aromas, complex flavor and a balanced acidity. Learn More & Pricing

Vanilla Fig Balsamic Vinegar

Our Vanilla Fig aged balsamic vinegar is culinary delight that dances between tradition and innovation. This balsamic vinegar is a testament to the craft of ancient artisans carried forth into the present. Learn More & Pricing

Watermelon Balsamic Vinegar

Just in for a limited time! Sweet, red, crispy, juicy watermelon flavors…just like summertime, are just a few of the words that describe this refreshing Balsamic Vinegar. Learn More & Pricing

White Riserva Balsamic Vinegar

In Italy, this is known as White Balsamic Condiment. Made with White Trebbiano Grape Must (juice), it does not undergo the cooking and barrel aging process of Balsamic Vinegar of Modena. The result is crisp vinegar with a touch of sweetness reminiscent of hand crafted vinegars from northern Italy. Learn More & Pricing